breakout: normandy
 |
Updated
Feb. 5, 2014
2013 WBC Report
|
2014 Status: pending 2014
GM commitment |
|
 |
Michael Kaye, MD
|
2013 Champion
|


|
WBC Event History |
1994 |
|
Jim Doughan |
|
50 |
1995 |
|
Bill Edwards |
|
48 |
1996 |
|
Hank Burkhalter |
|
54 |
1997 |
|
Jim Doughan |
|
53 |
1998 |
|
Don Greenwood |
|
52 |
1999 |
|
Michael Rinella |
|
48 |
2000 |
|
Phil Barcafer |
|
32 |
2001 |
|
Jim Doughan |
|
34 |
2002 |
|
Alan Applebaum |
|
26 |
2003 |
|
Jim Eliason |
|
28 |
2004 |
|
Nels Thompson |
|
33 |
2005 |
|
Andrew Cummins |
|
27 |
2006 |
|
Jim Eliason |
|
19 |
2007 |
|
Jim Doughan |
|
20 |
2008 |
|
Nels Thompson |
|
20 |
2009 |
|
Nels Thompson |
|
20 |
2010 |
|
Nels Thompson |
|
16 |
2011 |
|
Marvin Birnbaum |
|
21 |
2012 |
|
Kevin Hammond |
|
18 |
2013 |
|
Michael Kaye |
|
26 |
|
Rank Name From Last Total
1. Don Greenwood MD 13 388
2. Nels Thompson VA 13 324
3. Andrew Cummins uk 14 316
4. Michael Kaye MD 14 237
5. Marvin Birnbaum NY 13 211
6. Alan Applebaum MA 02 204
7. Jim Doughan PA 09 187
8. Jim Eliason IA 12 185
9. Bryan Eshleman NC 11 169
10. Mark Gutfreund KY 14 167
11. Tom Dworschak GA 12 156
12. Henry Jones PA 14 144
13. Mike Rinella NY 13 140
14. Scott Fenn MD 14 130
15. Brun Passacantando CT 12 128
16. Kevin Hammond NY 13 93
17. Steve Andriakos TX 10 88
18. Phil Barcafer PA 01 84
19. Clyde Longest VA 06 60
20. Ken Nied KS 05 51
21. David Wong NJ 03 50
22. Tom Pavy OH 03 48
23. Bill Edwards VA 99 36
24. Peter Brunken de 14 24
25. Harvey Smallman CA 07 24
26. Bryan Stingley NC 03 24
27. Tom Gregorio PA 10 22
28. Scott Moll VA 10 22
29. Chris Byrd CT 06 20
30. Matthew Ellis uk 10 18
31. Nick Anner NY 06 12
32. Anthony Daw UT 06 12
33. Anders Egneus sw 99 12
34. Ron Fedin PA 04 11
35. John Crabtree CA 01 10
36. Tom Drueding MA 04 10
37. Kevin Wojtaszczyk NY 11 8
38. Hank Burkhalter GA 10 7
39. John Grant Jr CT 99 6
40. Chris Roginsky PA 04 5
41. Dennis Nicholson NY 03 5
|
2013 Laurelists
Repeating
Laurelists:    |

Nels Thompson, NY
2nd |

Don Greenwood, MD
3rd |

Kevin Hammond, WA
4th |

Mike Rinella, NY
5th |

Marvin Birnbaum, NY
6th |
|
Past Winners |
Jim Doughan, PA
1994, 1997, 2001, 2007 |
Bill Edwards, VA
1995 |
Hank Burkhalter, TX
1996 |
Don Greenwood, MD
1998 |

Michael Rinella, NY
1999 |
Phil Barcafer, PA
2000 |
Alan Applebaum, MA
2002 |

Jim Eliason, IA
2003, 2006 |
Nels Thompson, NY
2004, 2008-10 |

Andrew Cummins, uk
2005 |
Marvin Birnbaum, NY
2011
|
Kevin Hammond, WA
2012
|
Michael Kaye, MD
2013
|
|
|
|
|
|
Grant LaDue and Eric Tolentino
|
Paul O'Neil faces 1999 champ Mark
Rinella.
|
Still hitting the beach 20 years
later ... via Canada
This was the year that the other shoe dropped in the Breakout
Normandy Tournament. The L2 version of the game has been
available for a couple of years but the shark pool that is the
player tournament group have previously by and large stuck to
the tried and tested Avalon Hill rules set. It might have been
helped by the substantially larger turnout this year (up to 26
players thanks to a demo and B rating) but L2 was the variant
of choice, not by a small margin, but convincingly so (nine AH
to 17 L2 games). Having crossed this rules set Rubicon, with
no one objecting to playing L2, next years event will be purely
L2. Of course a player with the AH set can still use it with
L2 rules so this shouldn't dissuade anyone from playing - and
the L2 game is every bit as exciting and tense as the original
version as we've seen in this tournament.
The
bidding this year fell back from the peaks of previous events
with most people opting to play out of the box - 0 in the L2,
35 in AH. The exceptions being attempts to force Allied or German
technicians out of their comfort zones. Ignoring the Mulligan
round which had a lot of training games, the overall split of
results was 11 German wins to six Allied. Perhaps even in the
L2 game the Allies need some bidding love to achieve their fair
share of results.
No Breakout event would be complete without a discussion
of the curious events that took place on the route to victory
(or defeat). Games with no weather changes as against multiple
weather changes each day. The three-impulse 8th which often seals
an Allied player's fate versus the ten-impulse 8th which allowed
me to overcome my four-impulse 7th against Steve Koleszar. Cold
dice doomed my further progress against Marvin in the second
round while sealing his fate against Don Greenwood in the third.
While we all rail against the slings and arrows of outrageous
fortune the dice throw at us, it is this variability that keeps
us coming back to the game for the strange situations and challenges
that inevitably arise.
The field of players this year was strong, with seven former
WBC champions in contention. Mike Kaye's route to the top was
not easy, facing defending champion Kevin Hammond in a nail-biting
semifinal where he needed a +3 roll as the Allies (with advantage)
to clear Caen in the closing impulses of the game. Recognising
that this was going to be his best shot for the game, he characteristically
went for it and secured his place in the Final with a fortuitous
roll.
In the L2 Final, the bidding reached 30 for the Allies, demonstrating
Nels Thompson's reluctance to face Mike Kaye's Allies. An early
decision point came with Nels rerolling an attack to clear Bretteville
on the 6th rather than hold it against the potential loss of
the magic bridge. This, combined with a decision to fight for
St Mere rather than reallocating into Omaha put the Allies on
the backfoot. Stir in weather changes on the first three days
with unrelenting German counterattacks into Isigny and you have
a real bare-knuckle game. Caen was the key with Nels initally
successfully enveloping the strongly held city, taking Troan,
Bourguebus, Verson and Evercy. But Mike struck back, reclaiming
Verson and reestablishing access that guaranteed the city would
not fall. This gave the veteran contender his first BKN title after decades in the trenches while denying Nels an unprecedented
fifth BKN championship.
|
|
Kevin Wojtaszczyk and Michael Kaye
anticipate a good dice roll.
|
Bob Basa faces two-time champ Jim
Eliason in the opening round.
|
Play By Email 2014
Andrew Cummins, relieved of his GM hat and responsibiliies
during the email wars, has won the 8th BPA PBeM tournament over
a field of 30 in 29 hotly contested games. In doing so, he has
become only the second player to win the BKN triple crown with
titles at WBC, the PBeM crown and the now defunct D-Day mini-con.
The Final took on a decidedly international and historical
flavor with UK's Andrew commanding the Allies against German
Peter Brunken's Wehrmacht. Despite nearly losing Juno Beach on
D-Day, Andrew was able to clear Omaha and contest St Mere Eglise
on the 6th. This led to the fall of Carentan on the 8th, usually
a fatal blow to German hopes. Andrew finished them off by isolating
Foret on the 10th—all but ensuring his last required VP.
In contrast to the most recent WBC, this event—which started
in 2012—used the original AH version as the default, leaving
use of the L2 version to those who mutually opted for its use.
The other laurelists were the 2013 WBC champ, Mike Kaye, in third
followed by veterans Scott Fenn, Henry Jones and defending champ
Mark Gutfreund.
|
|
|
|