settlers of catan [Updated October 2003]  

2003 WBC Report     

 2004 Status: pending 2004 GM commitment

Charlie Faella, RI

2003 Champion

2nd: George Brach, MA

3rd: Tom Saal, MI

4th: Mike Musko, FL

5th: Charlie Hickok, PA

6th: Bill Duke, MD

Event History
1999    Brad Johnson       94
2000    David Platnick     175
2001    Craig O'Brien       93
2002    David Buchholz     102
2003    Charlie Faella     131

Euro Quest Event History
2003    Brian Reynolds       29
Offsite links:
AREA Ratings

boardgamegeek 

 Laurels
Rank Name

From

Last
Total
 1. Charlie Faella

RI

03
60
 2. David Buchholz

MI

02
60
 3. Craig O'Brien

VA

01
60
 4. David Platnick

VA

00
60
 5. Kathy Stroh

PA

01
54
 6. Christian Moffa

NJ

03
54
 7. George Brach

MA

03
36
 8. Brian Conlon

OK

00
36
 9. Brian Reynolds

MD

03
30
10. Brad Johnson

IL

99
30
11. Joe Jaskiewicz

MD

01
30
12. Tom Saal

MI

03
24
13. Alan Sudy

VA

02
24
14. Kim Foster

TX

00
24
15. Mike Musko

FL

03
18
16. Marvin Pinkert

MD

02
18
17. Chuck Krueger

MA

01
18
18. Ike Porter

MD

99
18
19. Charlie Hickok

PA

03
12
20. Scott Buckwalter

MD

03
12
21. Jon Shambeda

PA

02
12
22. Jenn Thomas

NY

02
12
23. Kevin Wojtaszczyk

NY

01
12
24. Josh Githens

SC

00
12
25. Chuck Smith

PA

99
12
26. Tom McCorry

PA

03
  9
27. Carl Damcke

IL

99
  9
28. Bill Duke

MD

03
  6
29. Katherine McCorry

PA

03
  6
30. Roy Gibson

MD

99
  6
31. Joshua Cooper

MD

03
  3
32. Jamie Tang

MD

99
  3

Past Winners

Brad Johnson - IL
1999

David Platnick - VA
2000

Craig O'Brien - VA
2001

David Buchholz - MI
2002
     
 


Spiel das Jahre 1995 ...

This year's tournament witnessed an improved draw. Over 130 settlers attended the contest this year, a good jump from last year. By my count, 25 or so settlers were wearing the "one-day" badges. This is another indication of the continuing popularity of 1996s "Game of the Year".

The format of this year's fest mirrored last years. Random set up, random dice rolls, random decks were all standard fare. The addition of placing a city instead of a second settlement and placing a third road at start were items introduced from the KOSMOS tournament in Germany. I'll continue to have us mirror their concepts in future years. The tournament specific rule of not being able to play a Knight card before rolling the production dice will be re-considered for next year. Any future 'tinkering' (or reduction of 'tinkering') will have ease and speed of play in mind.

The assistant GMs for this event earned their pay this year. At 9 o'clock, the line for entering the tournament was nearly out the Valley Ballroom door, despite starting the sign up at 8.30. I'll have to go to three lines next year! Despite the number of entrants, we had everyone seated by 9.20. If you can manage it, bring a copy of the game! We had a number of people without a game this year. One kind soul gave me two sets to use. (If you are that kind soul, please contact me, as I have recovered those games.) The tournament consisted of three preliminary rounds. Entrants could (and some did) miss a round, but this made it impossible for them to advance to the semi-finals. Still, if you're coming to play, instead of pursue the wood, you are more than welcome to play, as long as you give me the word that you're leaving. First round was set at random, with each subsequent round sorted to keep players with the same level of points playing together, as reason allowed. Each player was awarded Tournament Points for their placement in their games. Five points for 1st, three for 2nd, two for 3rd and one point for 4th place were earned. Ties for a position simply split the points earned. The top 16 scorers would advance to the semi-finals. A published procedure was used for resolving ties. This used a percentage of points earned at the table.

The time limit was set at 90 minutes per game. This included set-up of the map as well as playing out the game. With over 130 entrants playing in nearly 100 games, it's a credit to the players as well as the tournament rules (thank KOSMOS) that none of the games were adjudicated (for the second year in a row!).

As the preliminaries drew to a close, the pencils and calculators were brought out. Last year, the tournament point count needed was 11. This year, the cut off was 11.5. A special acknowledgement goes to Su Hung. She lost all three games last year and ended up as the 17th ranked player this year, a clear winner of the "Most Improved" award. In addition, she pointed out a scoring error on her card that would have had her firmly in the top 16. She was good enough to remain at the GM table until it was verified that our 16 semi-finalists were present. Congrats to Su for being the Settler's Sportsmanship Award winner. On another front, we had two undefeated settlers going in to the semi-finals. Charles Hickock and Bill Duke were wearing their targets as the tables were set for the "Sweet 16". After a 90 minute round, Mike Musko, Charlie Faella, Thomas Saal and George Brace were left standing.

As the Finals board was set-up, there was much deliberation about initial settlement placement. There was a clear dearth of Brick and Ore locations. Each flavor had a single effective payout number. Nearly one-third of the game time was devoted to the critical initial placements. The great difficulty in obtaining Brick and Ore, let alone trading for it, was evidenced by the purchase of Roads for eight Sheep and Settlements for 10 Commodity cards. Scores reached 5, 6, 7 & 7 points without anyone taking ownership of the Special 2 point cards.

Despite the hard scoring environment, Charlie Faella met the 10 point goal ahead of the other finalists. Final scores: 10,9,8,7.

Thanks to everyone who entered. I'm already looking forward to next year.



 Eighteen little Settlers contested the WBC Settlers of Catan Juniors title. The best of these proved to be Tim De Marco of New Jersey who won, not only WBC wood, but better yet, braggin' rights over the rest of the famliy which went woodless this year. Carolyn Strock who came in second gets a sportsmanship nod for not complaining about the gender alliance that was set against her by three boys who continually set the robber against her even when she was not in the lead. Expect that alliance to change change with time. The other finalists, in order, were:

Carolyn Strock - PA

Vincent Alonso - VA

Zach Dunn - VA

 GM      Jeff Paull  [2nd Year]   10293 Merriam Lane, Twinsburg, OH 44087 
    jpaull@msn.com    NA

2003 Preview Page | View the Icon Key | Return to main BPA page