|
Fine porcelain! Bolts and bolts
of fabric! Spices for sale!
For another year, the GM was very happy with the turnout for
the event in the three preliminary heats. However, there were
even more players who qualified but did not attend the semi-final
round, making the GM wonder what he can do to improve attendance
for the semi-final round, although the number of semi-finalists
participating in the round has worked out to the
optimal number of players for the past three years. The GM prefers
5-player games if possible, and uses either 4-player games or
6-player games as necessary to fill the field in each heat.
Heat
1 on Wednesday afternoon had 11 games, including one 4-player
game. In the most notable, Ellis Simpson got five dye commodities
and Gary Noe four cloth commodities in the first round. Both
players made it to the 20-point bonus level in the second round,
but it didn't help as Ellis finished a distant fifth while Gary
did a scarcely better fourth. John Kerr won this game by getting
the highest boat, including the "gold" card on the
final set of commodities in the third round. This round also
saw two players, Robert Cranshaw and Eugene Lin, win with 25-point
victory margins, the highest in the tournament. Other winners
in the first heat were Alex Gesing, Steve Scott, David Platnik,
Aaron Fuegi, Tom Dunning, Jeff Mullet, Rhonda Reiff and Bill
Beckman.
Heat 2 occurred on Thursday afternoon and was one of the highest
attended heats that I have ever had in this tournament. 13 games
were played including three 6-player versions. Tom DeMarco won
his game in which the players didn't bid on a lot of cards in
each of the rounds, leaving many players repeatedly without full
boats. Brendan Tracey was the only player in the first round
of his game who could take a load of three commodities and ended
up getting the two "5-spice" and the "gold"
card on his draw, leading him to an easy victory. In the GM's
game, Peter Staab, Chris Gnech and Charles Faella all had four
of a commodity in the first round of the game. However, only
Chris made the bonus level in the second round (and only the
10-level). In fact, Peter didn't make the top level in his commodity
at all, but Alex Gesing did by getting four of this commodity
in the third round. However, Charles did manage to get to the
bonus level in two commodities and won handily. This heat also
saw another 25-point victory, this time by Michael Musko. Other
winners in this heat were Rich Zelano, Jason Levine, Harold Henning,
Kevin Youells, Fred Minard, Gary Noe, Benjamin Foy and David
Fritsh.
Heat 3 was played again on Saturday evening for the second
year in a row, but moved up to try to get the semi-final and
final finished earlier and avoid conflicts between this heat
and other events. There were only nine games played in this heat
including one 4-player. In this heat, Bruce Reiff called his
shot in the final round by stating that he needed "any metal,
the 10-card and any 5 to win." Bruce then proceeded to turn
over a 0-metal, the 10 and a 5-spice card and fulfilled his prophecy.
This heat also saw the only double winner in the preliminaries
as Joe Jaskiewicz won his second. The other games in this heat
were won by Kathy Stroh, Laurel Stokes, Larry Loiacono, Peter
Staab, Bill Burch, Gary Presser and Ted Mullally.
The semi-final began immediately after the end of the third
heat as has been the tournament format since its inception. The
32 different Preliminary winners yielded 25 who chose to advance
- allowing five 5-player games with the winners advancing to
the final. Gary Presser and Bruce Reiff tied in their game with
Gary winning the tiebreaker. Eugene Lin won his test even though
he was the only player not to score bonus points in the final
round. Ben Foy, Gary Noe and Peter Staab also won to round out
the finalists.
The seating order was randomly determined as stated in the
tournament format, with Gary Presser getting the honor of being
the first player followed by Peter Staab, Gary Noe, Eugene Lin
and Benjamin Foy in clockwise order. In the first round, Peter
paid 12 florins to get a combination of a "5-cloth"
and "4-cloth" card on his deal, and then on the next
deal got three more cloth cards (values of 3,5, and 0) for 10
additional florins. At this point, Presser complained that Noe
allowed Peter to have these cards and was giving him the game.
However, Foy managed to snag four different spice commodity cards
in the first round as well and these two large sets of commodities
did not prevent Presser from leading after the first round with
55 florins, followed by Noe at 52, Eugene at 37, Peter at 28
and Ben at 26 florins. In the second round, both Peter and Ben
managed to make it to the 20-point bonus level of their respective
commodities. Late in the turn, Presser decided to pass on a set
of cards that would have gotten him second place in the boat
size and two moderately useful commodities to try to get the
top boat since many of the higher cards had not been seen in
the round. However, lady luck was against Gary as he drew two
low cards to end up third in boat size and the commodities didn't
help him either. After the second round, Presser still held the
lead at 75 florins, followed by Noe at 65, Eugene at 60, Peter
at 59 and Ben at 55. In the final round, Peter completed his
ship early and assured himself of the biggest boat with the commodities
that he got. This turned out to be a good move as the last round
saw too many cards burned. Some players, especially Presser,
didn't complete their ships and the prices escalated as commodity
cards became scarce. Eugene made a valiant try to catch Peter
in the end, but wound up bidding too much on the last bid. Peter
won the event at 90 florins to Eugene's 88. Noe came in third
at 86 florins, Ben squeaked into fourth at 82 florins and Presser
brought up the rear with 81 florins.
The games are getting closer and closer after six years of
competition. This year, there were three ties - compared to only
two in all five of the prior events combined. The largest margin
of victory in a game this year was 25 florins, as compared to
numerous blowouts of over 30 florins in prior years. Finally,
the difference between first and last in the final was only nine
florins so everyone was competitive in the final to the end as
compared to a lot of games where one player falls behind early
and can never catch up. I am very impressed with the improved
skill levels and play in this game that has occurred over the
years - even though all five of this year's other laurelists
were new to the chart.
I plan to GM Medici again in 2004 and plan to keep the schedule
as it was last year. If you have any suggestions to improve the
tournament, please let me know your ideas at the address below.
I hope that those of you who played this summer lenjoyed the
tournament and that my regular players who couldn't make the
event last year can fit it into their schedule in Lancaster.
Finally, I've had some complaints about the tiebreaker that I
amcurrently using. If you have any suggestions about a good tiebreaker
for this tournament, please contact me.
|