 |
 |
|
So far, E&T has defied the "Here
Today, Gone tomorrow" rep of most Euro events. |
E&T was voted Legacy status in
2008 after ten years of consistent performance. |
Acquiring Civilization ...
Legacy status returned Reiner Kniza's tile placing masterpiece
Euphrat & Tigris to the convention as a Legacy event
this year. Despite that and the enhanced prize level, attendance
was down to a record low 36 players, possibly due to conflicts
with the scheduled Sunday morning Final.
The tournament again used a rules variant this year to balance
the advantage of the first two players. Instead of their normal
two actions, the first two players received only one action for
the first turn only. For the elimination rounds, the higher seeded
player was offered the choice of playing first or third. The
distribution of wins for 4-player games was 4 - (31%), 4 - (31%),
4 - (31%), 1 (8%) for players moving first through fourth, respectively.
This variant continues to offer better player balance and will
remain in place next year.
|
Dynasty \ Finish |
Win |
2nd |
3rd |
4th |
Avg Finish |
|
Archer 1st (1 action) |
4 |
5 |
2 |
2 |
2.15 |
|
Bull 2nd (1 action) |
4 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
2.53 |
|
Lion 3rd |
4 |
4 |
3 |
2 |
2.23 |
|
Potter 4th |
1 |
2 |
5 |
5 |
3.07 |
Seven winners plus the best five runners-up from the preliminary
heats rounded out three semi-final tables. In the first semi-final,
Marc Berenbauch (8-8-8-8) defeated Patrick Shea (7-7-8-8) and
defending champion Alfred Smith. Patrick was only two hypothetical
treasures behind the winner but would have to wait to see if
his tiebreaker held up. In the second game, leading laurelist
Jeff Cornett scored a solid win as the Archers over prior champion
Matt Calkins and perennial finalist Rob Kilroy. In the last semi-final,
former GM Mark Guttag made his first E&T Final by edging
Brian Stone10-10-11-15 to 9-9-11-13. In this case, Brian needed
three hypothetical treasures to reach 10-11-11-13 to pass Mark.
This was not close enough and Patrick advanced as the closest
runner-up.
Turn order preferences for the Final were similar to earlier
rounds. Marc had first choice and selected 3rd player. Jeff (1st),
Mark. (2nd), and Patrick (4th) rounded out the table. Jeff and
Mark used their only first round action to start kingdoms with
their Farmer and Priest respectively. However, during the second
round they both chose to place two other leaders in a different
area, Jeff in the center and Mark in the northwest. Meanwhile,
Marc quickly claimed the southwest treasure with his Trader and
Patrick got two eastern treasures as he stretched his kingdom
out tenuously to link with Jeff's Farmer.
In the first conflict Marc defeated Jeff's farmer to score
four blue VP. Patrick then consolidated the remaining kingdoms
while claiming his third treasure. Stability reigned for several
turns as the players built up support for four closely matched
kingdoms. Finally Marl's kingdom in the north stretched too far
in claiming a treasure and enticed Patrick to attack with his
King. Unfortunately for Patrick, Jeff removed most of his newly
found support by splitting the kingdom with a catastrophe in
order to avoid a rout. Since there were no temples open in the
center kingdom, Mark took the rare action of removing his Priest
from the board to make room for his King to attack Jeff in his
second action with an internal conflict.
The endgame was punctuated by several large external conflicts.
Mark won a green battle against Jeff for five points. Marc won
two battles and gained three black, three green, and a treasure.
Jeff ended the game by using a catatrophe and dropping in his
Trader to claim the last treasure. In the final tally, Marc won
with a low score of eight reds (8/9/9/10) on his 30th birthday.
Patrick (6/6/7/9), Jeff (6/6/7/8), and Mark (5/6/6/11) claimed
the other laurels in that order.
Next year, the 1/1/2/2 action rules variant and hypothetic
treasure margin-of-victory tiebreaker will be kept. The GM would
like to thank everyone for their participation and is looking
forward to another great event next year.
 |
 |
|
Original GM Mark Guttag, Janet Ottey,
Phillies backer Rob Kilroy, and defending champ Alfred Smith
in Preliminary play. |
Ex-champs Jeff Cornett and John Kilbride
join Craig Melton in Preliminary Round play. |
|