|
|
Ivan Lawson, David Metzger, Lee Mewshaw
and Rod Davidson |
Haim Hochboim, Tom DeMarco, and Karl
Henning |
Changing of the Guard ...
Not only did three-time defending champ Andy Latto not repeat,
none of last year's top six tasted laurels again in 2010. This
year's semi-finals proved to be a family affair, featuring 2009
runner-up Karl Henning and his brother Nick, and 2006 champion
Anne Norton and her husband and previous finalist Tom DeMarco.
Three-time defending champion Andy Latto had his streak ended
by Ted Bohaczuk in the first heat. Karl could not repeat his
performance in last year's semi's, leaving his brother to defend
the family's honor, but Anne won her semi to return to the familiar
territory of the Final table for a third time. A third semi-final
game was decided by the closest of margins. Aran Warzsawski and
Arthur Field finished in a tie, and the usual tiebreaker did
not apply, since neither of them had triggered the endgame. But
Aran was to the immediate left of David Meyaard, the player who
did trigger the end of the game, and this was sufficient to break
the tie and advance him. Romain Jacques of Quebec rounded out
the final four, giving us an international Final with competitors
from three different countries.
While Thurn and Taxis has a lot of skill, there is of course
a chance element in the game too. In the Final, Nick had possibly
the worst luck I have ever seen in the game. Twice he was forced
to clear the board to attempt to extend his route, and in both
cases, none of the 13 cards he saw (six before clearing, six
after, and a desperation blind draw) was useful, and he was forced
to discard his route. Romain needed Pilsen to provide a connection
to Lodz for the all-countries visited bonus, and eventually obtained
a Pilsen card, but only by clearing five times in succession,
losing valuable time. Aran sat to Romain's left, so reaped the
benefit of often seeing a set of fresh cards. This combined with
good play was enough to best the former champion at the table
for the title.
This year's results seem to indicate an advantage to going
first; out of 35 games played, the first player won 12, compared
to six wins for the second player, nine for the third player,
and eight for the player going last. Combining that with last
year's results, though, we have a total of 19 wins for first,
14 for second, 15 for third, and 14 for fourth, so while there
seems to be a first player advantage, it is smaller than this
year's results seem to imply. Oddly enough, all four semi-final
games resulted in a win for the third player, and the Final was
won by the player going last. The advantages of early position
are obvious, with first shot at six new cards on Turn 1, and
being one turn ahead in claiming bonus chits first. The advantage
of the later positions, controlling the timing of the game by
deciding whether to trigger the endgame or continue for an extra
turn, are more subtle. Perhaps the better players in the semi-finals
have discovered how to use this to balance the advantage of the
first player. At any rate, any first player advantage does not
seem large enough to warrant bidding for position, so we will
continue to use random seating in 2011.
|
|
Carmen Petruzelli, Karl Henning, Romain
Jacques and Kevin Wojtaszcyk |
Attendance bounced back for T&T
after an inexplicable down year in 2009. |
|