 |
 |
|
Brian Mountford, Liam Dyer, Jack Doughan
and Bill Dyer chase worms in the first heat. |
The six finalists at work deep in
the bowels of the Lancaster Host on Saturday morning. |
The Spice of Life
We had ten qualifying games this year, up from only eight
the last two years. It was really great to welcome some new players,
even though a few of the regulars were among the missing. Dune
players are a small group but very loyal to the game. More than
a third of the field played in all three heats. The big change
was the addition of a new house rule to address balance of the
Fremen. The Fremen were granted the additional ability of always
getting full combat value for their tokens in sand territories
for no cost. The decision to add this rule resulted from a recent
poll. Over the past ten years, the Fremen had been winning only
about 20% of their games, compared to an average of nearly 40%
for the other factions. In Dune, victories are frequently
shared among two or three allies. Although these numbers remained
virtually unchanged by the new rule, the feedback was universally
positive. The options available to the Fremen player, especially
in the early game, seemed to be significantly improved, and consequently
the Fremen experience was more enjoyable. As experience with
the new ability increases, the Fremen's win record may rise accordingly
- or so the theory goes.
The average game lasted 4.1 hours and spanned 6.8 game turns,
a slight decrease from last year, but still in the "normal"
range. Variation in win percentages among the factions was also
down quite a bit: Bene Gesserit, Emperor, and Harkonnen wins
were virtually identical in the middle. Atreides took a big fall
to fifth place from top faction last year, while Fremen brought
up the rear again. The Guild, on the other hand, continued its
four-year climb in the standings to emerge as the top faction
for the first year on record! Dune is always a game of
surprises, and this year was no different. Interesting anecdotes
included an Emperor being funded by a Fremen ally, a Turn 2 Guild/Harkonnen
victory fueled by traitor calls and hand swaps, and a BG solo
win by predicting the Guild in Turn 5!
As always, Best Faction plaques were awarded to the players
with the best single-game performance as each faction during
the preliminary heats, measured in terms of strongholds controlled
per turn. Newcomer James Denam took home Best Atreides; Steve
Cuccaro, Best BG; Jim Garvey, Best Emperor; Stephane Dorais,
Best Fremen; Matt Fagan, Best Guild; and Joe Doughan, Best Harkonnen.
Special note: With this award, Matt Fagan has become the first
player to collect a full set of Best Faction plaques, having
also won Best Atreides in 2005, Best BG in 2003, Best Emperor
in 2004, Best Fremen in 2007, and Best Harkonnen in 2008. Congratulations
for having the skill and perseverance to achieve a goal I wasn't
sure could ever be possible!
In the Final, Joe Harrison returned as the Atreides (for the
third year running!), Matt Fagan drew the Bene Gesserit, Ty Hansen
was the Emperor, Joe Doughan (subbing for Steve Cuccaro) took
the Fremen, James Denam got the Guild, and Wray Ferrell drew
the Harkonnen.
The Emperor made an early move, kicking the Guild out of Tuek's
Sietch, while the Fremen held Sietch Tabr and the Atreides and
Harkonnen remained in their cities. The Guild returned to the
planet in Habbanya Ridge Sietch, and then House Harkonnen took
Tabr away from the Fremen. This situation remained relatively
stable until mid-game, when the Guild and Atreides began squabbling
over Arrakeen. First, the Emperor and then the Atreides replaced
the Harkonnen in Carthag, all without the Shield Wall protecting
them from the storm. Negotiation was hot and heavy throughout
the game, with several looking to gain advantage through creative
use of Truthtrances and Karamas. The Emperor took control of
the Shield Wall and then regained Tuek's Sietch from the Atreides,
but no one was able to build a decisive dominance. Finally, in
the late turns, the BG emerged from the shadows and brought force
to Arrakis in earnest, allied with the Emperor. Together, they
were just able to control four strongholds, wresting HRS away
from the Guild, who had held it for nearly the entire game, and
barely beating the Harkonnen, who were a mere one spice short
of successfully defending the Shield Wall. The Emperor won the
second tie-breaker by virtue of retaining nearly his full army
intact on the planet.
Congratulations to Ty Hansen for his first Dune title
as part of a triple title year, and thanks to everyone for another
great year! Let's try to gain a prize level in 2012!
|