successors   

Updated 11/17/2011

2011 WBC Report    

  2012 Status: not eligible for December Membership Trial Vote *

Craig Melton, VA

2011 Champion

Links

AREA Boardgamegeek Laurels
ConSimWorld GMT Games Recommended

  

Event History
1998    Doug Smith      32
1999    Jim Gutt     16
2000    Jim Gutt     16
2001     Robert Seulowitz     17
2002     Robert Seulowitz      16
2003     Doug Smith      18
2004     Henry Rice      17
2005     Ross Jones      18
2006     Doug Smith      24
2007     Doug Smith      22
2008     Doug Smith      12
2009     Henry Rice      23
2010     Rob Seulowitz      13
2011     Craig Melton      19

PBeM Event History
2004    Rob Mull      24
 Laurels

Rank  Name               From  Last  Total
  1.  Doug Smith          PA    11    135
  2.  Rob Seulowitz       NY    11    106
  3.  Jim Gutt            AZ    04    101
  4.  Henry Rice          NM    09     90
  5.  Ross Jones          SC    06     70
  6.  Craig Melton        VA    11     51
  7.  Rob Mull            CO    04     50
  8.  Ahmet Ilpars        tu    08     42
  9.  Ralph Gleaton       SC    10     34
 10.  Keith Wixson        NJ    10     31
 11.  Tim Miller          GA    03     30
 12.  Michael Day         AZ    02     30
 13.  Phil Rodrigues      VA    11     30
 14.  Bruce Blumentritt   TX    11     24
 15.  Stefan MeCay        TX    04     20
 16.  Stan Buck           MD    09     18
 17.  Dan Dolan Jr        NJ    08     18
 18.  Mark Hinkle         NH    04     18
 19.  Seth Gunar          NJ    10     15
 20.  Dan Blumentritt     TX    11     14
 21.  Francis Czawlytko   MD    08     14
 22.  Jim Doughan         PA    00     12
 23.  Matt Ellison        OH    04     10
 24.  Nick Firer          WI    00     10
 25.  Tom Drueding        MA    07      9
 26.  Dorian Key          DC    09      6
 27.  Chris Storzillo     NJ    05      6
 28.  J. R. Tracy         NY    00      6
 29.  Dennis Mason        ME    99      6
 30.  Risto Marjomaa      fn    04      5
 31.  Tom Constantine     ME    06      4
 32.  Peter Card          uk    00      4
 33.  Michael Mitchell    GA    99      3
 34.  Brian Mountford     NY    00      2

2011 Laurelists                                          Repeating Laurelists:

Bruce Blumentritt, TX
2nd

Phil Rodrigues, VA
3rd

Dan Blumentritt, TX
4th

Doug Smith, VA
5th

Rob Seulowitz, NY
6th

Past Winners

Doug Smith, PA
1998, 2003, 2006-08

Jim Gutt, AZ
1999-00

Robert Seulowitz, NY
2001-02, 2010

Henry Rice, NM
2004, 2009

Ross Jones, SC
2005

Keith Wixson and Seth Gunar get in their annual Successors fix before moving on to other favorites.

Bruce Blumentritt, Craig Melton, Phil Rodrigues, and Francis Czawlytko.

Triremes Triumph Over a Tenacious Triumvirate in Tumult

Congratulations to Craig Melton for winning his first Successors championship in 2011 ... and only eleven years after his last championship. Persistence pays! Attendance for this year was up slightly, and made up in enthusiasm and bloodthirstiness what it may have lacked in pure tonnage.

Special recognition is due to 11-year-old Eric Rodgers-Vargo, making his debut in any WBC event. Eric started with Antigonus and Ptolemy, and managed to make a strong run at the Regency win on Turn 3 only to be turned back by a desperation attack from Seth "Baby Crusher" Gunar. Eric proved to be an excellent competitor, hanging tough when things were not going his way, and treating his elders with respect (except on the battlefield, where he mostly kicked us like rented mules). Eric is not only welcome back next year, but downright commanded to so appear on the field of battle!

The Final featured two veterans in the form of Craig and the redoubtable Phil Rodrigues, as well as two relative newcomers in the return of the father/son combination of Bruce and Daniel Blumentritt. As was the case last year, any fear that the filial bond would influence play was dispelled early and often, as the Blumentritt's displayed an historically accurate and utterly Sophoclean willingness to undermine each other at any opportunity.

The finalists agreed to use the Reverse Draft method to select Generals. Craig drafted first to take Antipater, Bruce took Antigonus second, Daniel selected Perdiccas third and Phil got the Crateras/Peithon tandem in the double draft position. Daniel then choose Leonatus on the return as Bruce took Lysimachus seventh leaving Craig with Ptolemy and the Usuper.

 Start

Bruce

Craig

Daniel

Phil

 VP

6

9 (U)

6

4

Legit

3

5

10

3

Macedonians

4

6
 

6

Bruce immediately combined both generals to depose Antipater and claim Macedonia on Turn 1 to take a commanding position despite Daniel getting the Silver Shields early.

 End of Turn 1

Bruce

Craig

Daniel

Phil

 VP

6

6

9 (U)

7

Legit

7

3

10

3

Macedonians

5

3

8

6

On Turn 2, with a weak hand and the Usurper tag on him, Daniel considered burying the body in Babylon to let it vanish for 0 points (see the special WBC rules). However, as he was also "Condemned" and had "Hubris" cancel his marriage to "Cleopatra," he took a gamble on securing two much needed Legit Points. Phil held Palestine strongly, so Daniel sent Leonnatus from Caria up to Bithinia to besiege it and ran Perdiccas up that way. But Phil combined Craterus and Peithon into one big force and headed North to block. Meanwhile, with Bruce being thwarted in Thrace by rampaging Independents and 1-CU speed-bumps, Craig quietly took Rhodes, then mugged Leonatus to steal the Silver Shields and the come-back was launched.

End of Turn 2

Bruce

Craig

Daniel

Phil

 VP

6

12 (U)

9

11

Legit

7

3

7

3

Macedonians

6

4

9

7

Turn 3 opened with Craig back in the Usurper seat, and the gloves coming off. Phil took Craterus to Cappodicia to assassinate Leonatus and won the battle, then stomped on Perdiccas in Armenia to take Alex IV (giving him control of both heirs) and the Body. Unperturbed by the violence in Asia Minor, Craig slowly built VP in Judea, Cyrene, and Crete, plus taking Athens for unchallengeable command of the sea, while losing Lydia to Bruce as his only setback. Craig's land-grab kept him in first place on points and left Phil - who had drawn a lot of blood but hadn't claimed much territory - with no choice but to send Heracles to the Day Care Center in the Sky.

End of Turn 3

Bruce

Craig

Daniel

Phil

 VP

11

13 (U)

6

5

Legit

9

3

2

3

Macedonians

7

5

8

7

On Turn 4, Phil took Mespotamia and chased Perdiccas' re-formed army back all the way into Media. As Craig was now in striking distance of taking Phoenicia and Greece, the others all suspended hostilities to try and reduce his geographical footprint, but he had the cards and the skill to take back whatever they whittled off. On his last card play he first subjugated the Greek Island and then played Influence Spreads to take two more spaces in Greece, own the province, and win the game on VP.

 End of Game

Bruce

Craig

Daniel

Phil

 VP

15

23 W

4

5

Legit

9

3

2

3

Macedonians

9

5

8

8

In time honored fashion, Craig demonstrated the superiority of strategy over tactics, using command of the sea and ruthlessly efficient exploitation of the cards to come back from an early knock-down and win the title of Champion. Kudos and Huzzah!

Other notes:

In all qualifying games this year, tables were allowed to use any of the following optional rules if all players agreed:

1. Attrition: Over-stacked armies must roll on the attrition table, not simply lose 1 CU (used in four of five games).

2. Reverse Draw for Generals (used in 0 games).

3. Rhodes Defense: Any Naval move that ends on Rhodes while Rhodes is marked with an Independent Marker is subject to an automatic Naval Interception from the Rhodes fleet -- the Rhodes Fleet defends at a strength of 2 (used in two of five games)

For the Final, the "Pontic Fleet" card is removed and rule 23.5 is in effect (drafting Seleucus or Eumenes to replace a dead General).

To replace the three cards removed from the deck, I put in three that were ultimately rejected from the re-issue:

"Cleitus the White" - treats a naval battle as though you have a "3" General
"Cavalry Superiority" - get a column shift for control of one of four areas
and "Salavation in the Eleventh Hour," which is a card I have always loved (after all, it did actually happen to Perdiccas).
Thanks to one and all for their attendance and support. Special thanks to Daniel Blumentritt for his excellent reporting on the final game, much of which I have quoted verbatim.

Next year in Pella!

Links
Successors page at GMT: Includes downloadable version of the rule book and this excellent VASSAL module.
Successors (3rd Edition) page at Board Game Geek
Successors (3rd Edition) folder at ConSimWorld

* However, this may prove to be the last year for Successors at WBC. The Board has voted to eliminate from the membership ballot all events which have failed to draw the required minimum participation in seven of its last ten years. Successors, while proving, for whatever reasons, to be a perennial vote getter has failed to attract sufficient players to actually compete repeatedly, and in the final analysis that is what it's all about. If enough players do not participate, the slot is best opened for a more worthy candidate to get its chance in the limelight. It's only path to return in 2012 is via sponsorship.

Ben Campagna is stuck for a move.

Phil Rodrigues and Bruce Blumentritt
 GM      Robert Seulowitz [6th year]    NA 
    coinflip@verizon.net   NA

2011 Preview Page | View the Icon Key | Return to main BPA page