settlers of catan   

Updated Nov. 23, 2012

2012 WBC Report     

 2013 Status: pending 2013 GM commitment

Jeremy Osteen, MD

2012 Champion

Event History
1999    Brad Johnson       94
2000    David Platnick     175
2001    Craig O'Brien       93
2002    David Buchholz     102
2003    Charlie Faella     131
2004    Aran Warszawski     110
2005     Rob Effinger     100
2006    Roy Gibson     102
2007    Tom Stokes     132
2008     Matt Tolman     113
2009     Rick Dutton     113
2010    Robert Kircher     112
2011    Andrew Arconti     138
2012    Jeremy Osteen     116

Euro Quest Event History
2003    Brian Reynolds     29
2004    William Duke     30
2005     Legend Dan Hoffman     37
2006     Donna Dearborn     54
2007     Brian Reynolds     45
2008     Tom Dunning     56
2009     Brian Reynolds     55
2010    Rebecca Hebner     43
2011    Brian Reynolds     55
2012    Robert Kircher     43

 Laurels

Rank  Name              From  Last  Total
  1.  Rob Kircher        RI    12    126
  2.  Brian Reynolds     MD    12    125
  3.  Rick Dutton        MD    09    114
  4.  Charlie Faella     RI    09     96
  5.  Tom Dunning        NY    09     87
  6.  Jeremy Osteen      MD    12     84
  7.  Matt Tolman        UT    09     84
  8.  Andrew Arconti     MD    11     66
  9.  Roy Gibson         MD    06     66
 10.  Tom Stokes         NJ    07     60
 11.  Rob Effinger       on    05     60
 12.  Aran Warszawski    is    04     60
 13.  David Buchholz     MI    02     60
 14.  Craig O'Brien      VA    01     60
 15.  David Platnick     VA    00     60
 16.  Christian Moffa    NJ    03     54
 17.  Kathy Stroh        PA    01     54
 18.  Joe Jaskiewicz     MD    06     51
 19.  John Min           NJ    11     48
 20.  Virginia Colin     VA    12     42
 21.  Tom Saal           MI    10     42
 22.  Rodney Davidson    AZ    04     42
 23.  William Duke       MD    12     39
 24.  Cheryl Mallon      MD    07     37
 25.  Natasha Metzger    NY    12     36
 26.  Chad Martin        PA    12     36
 27.  Ron Secunda        MD    10     36
 28.  Ken Nied           KS    06     36
 29.  Jim Fishkin        FL    05     36
 30.  Michelle Hymowitz  MD    04     36
 31.  George Brace       MA    03     36
 32.  Brian Conlon       OK    00     36
 33.  Rebecca Hebner     DC    11     36
 34.  Josh Githens       SC    07     30
 35.  Donna Dearborn     MD    06     30
 36.  Brad Johnson       IL    99     30
 37.  Kolbe DiGiulio     PA    12     24
 38.  Harald Henning     CT    08     24
 39.  Jon Izer           MD    07     24
 40.  Jeff Bowers        UT    05     24
 41.  Alan Sudy          VA    02     24
 42.  Kim Foster         TX    00     24
 43.  Legend Dan Hoffman MD    05     20
 44.  Cary Morris        NC    12     18
 45.  Helen Powell       MD    11     18
 46.  Allyson Field      SC    11     18
 47.  Randy Buehler      WA    10     18
 48.  Bill Zurn          CA    10     18
 49.  Daniel Ottey       PA    09     18
 50.  Shivendra Chopra   MD    09     18
 51.  William Lawhorn    VA    09     18
 52.  Bob Wicks, Jr      CT    08     18
 53.  Mikkel Christensen dk    08     18
 54.  Pierre LeBoeuf     MD    07     18
 55.  Jed Shambeda       PA    06     18
 56.  Haim Hochboim      is    04     18
 57.  Mike Musko         FL    03     18
 58.  Marvin Pinkert     MD    02     18
 59.  Chuck Krueger      MA    01     18
 60.  Ike Porter         MD    99     18
 61.  Leigh Eirich       MD    10     12
 62.  Doug Galullo       MD    10     12
 63.  Peter Eirich       MD    10     12
 64.  Andrew Roosen      MD    09     12
 65.  Mike Brazinski     MD    08     12
 66.  Sue Lanham         MD    08     12
 67.  Bob Runnicles      FL    06     12
 68.  Mike Richey        VA    05     12
 60.  Thomas Browne      PA    04     12
 70.  David Burkey       PA    04     12
 71.  Charlie Hickok     PA    03     12
 72.  Scott Buckwalter   MD    03     12
 73.  Jon Shambeda       PA    02     12
 74.  Jenn Thomas        NY    02     12
 75.  Kevin Wojtasczcyk  NY    01     12
 76.  Chuck Smith        PA    99     12
 77.  Henry Dove         MD    12      9
 78.  Donna Davis        PA    12      9
 79.  Bill Murdock       NY    08      9
 80.  Tom McCorry        VA    03      9
 81.  Carl Damcke        IL    99      9
 82.  Eric Freeman       PA    07      8
 83.  Matt Reese         MD    12      6
 84.  Jeff Adams         NJ    11      6
 85.  Tom Strock         PA    10      6
 86.  John Weber         MD    09      6
 87.  Nick Henning       CT    08      6
 88.  Jonathan Yonce     VA    07      6
 89.  Michael Shea       CT    07      6
 90.  Phil Rennert       MD    06      6
 91.  Marty Hoff         TX    04      6
 92.  Katherine McCorry  VA    03      6
 93.  Larry Loiacano     PA    07      4
 94.  Andrew Gerb        MD    05      4
 95.  Steve Shambeda     PA    09      3
 96.  Sandy Scanlon      MD    08      3
 97.  Joshua Cooper      MD    03      3
 98.  Jamie Tang         MD    99      3
 99.  Laurel Stokes      NJ    05      2

2012 Laurelists                                                Repeating Laurelists:

Natasha Metzger, NY
2nd

Kolbe DiGiulio, PA
3rd

Virginia Colin, VA
4th

Chad Martin, PA
5th

Matt Reese, MD
6th

Past Winners

Brad Johnson, IL
1999

David Platnick, VA
2000

Craig O'Brien, VA
2001

David Buchholz, MI
2002

Charlie Faella, RI
2003

Aram Warszawski, Israel
2004

Rob Effinger, ON
2005

Roy Gibson, MD
2006

Tom Stokes, NJ
2007

Matt Tolman, UT
2008

Rick Dutton, MD
2009

Robert Kircher, RI
2010

Andrew Arconti, MD
2011

Jeremy Osteen, MD
2012
 

In her first WBC, Natasha Metzger becomes a finalist. No wonder David has so many championships.

Betsy Rau and Eve Secunda settle on that mysterious island of Catan with the crime problem.

 Matt Beach and Donna Balkan. Can she get two in one year?

 Jake must run the Circus on Catan.

Spiel das Jahre 1995 ...

Crazy Eights ...

This year we used the standard setup and consequently only a handful of games were called due to time. Most of those were games that started late and to help offset that I gave them an extra round at the 5 minute mark. Only one of the games did not score 10 points for a winner. This standard format will be used again in 2013 and for those that liked the faster pace game I ask you give it a try next year, especially since I will have a prize for all winners of any game next year.

The tournament format provides three qualifying rounds that advance 16 for a single elimination playoff. All games were consecutive and it makes for a full day for players and the GM. Players achieved tournament points based on finishing position and bonus points based on the strength of victories. Seating was random and players earned 5 points for 1st, 3 for 2nd, 2 for 3rd and 1 for 4th. Once the first three rounds were completed, the top 16 players then entered into a playoff round, based on performance in the first three rounds.

The first three rounds generated the following statistics. The games averaged 77 minutes, with the fastest game clocking in at 40 minutes and the longest at 120 minutes. A total of 63 games were played: 24 in Round 1, 22 in Round 2 and 17 in Round 3. Only one 3-player game was played, and it happened that the last place player in that game won the tournament. We had two triple winners advance to the semifinal, but no further. The magic number for advancement was 10 tournament points -- two wins, or a win, a 2nd and a 3rd place. Two qualifiers, Ben Scholl and Jon Senn, gave up their seat to play in another event, which allowed two lucky alternates to advance -- a first since I have been running the event. One of the finalists did not play in Round 1, yet won her next three games to advance to the Final. So, late entry does not eliminate you. In Settlers, anything is possible.

The 16 qualifiers for Round 4 were: Chad Martin, Dana Champion, Kolbe DiGuilo and Chester Lanham at Table 1; Matt Reese, Natasha Metzger, John Rinko and Rich Miller at Table 2; Forrest Speck, Jeremy Osteen, Carolyn Strock and Erica Kirchner at table 3; and Steve Dickson, Kevin Youells, Tammy Wyatt-Johnson and Virginia Colin at Table 4. The semifinals lasted about 75 minutes and advanced Virgina Colin, Jeremy Osteen, Kolbe DiGuilo and Natasha Metzger to the Final. Chad Martin and Matt Reese, the two triple winners, both were runners-up in their respective games and were awarded fifth and sixth place. Ty Hansen gave a free copy of the Catan Scenarios: Oil Springs expansion that he designed (along with Erik Assadourian) to all 16 participants.

Colin and Osteen were ranked players with 24 laurels each in former tournaments. Metzger and DiGuillo were unranked. Metzger was first, followed by Colin, Osteen and DiGuillo. The initial placement was crucial: the Osteen 6s were on a field (wheat) and forest (wood) while the 8s were on a clay (brick) and forest (Wood); one note was the 6-wheat was next to a 2:1 wheat port while the 8 was next to a 2:1 brick port. This would be a key to the end-game. Key locations: Metzger took the 6/9/2 location on the 6-wheat and next to the wheat port, Metzger took the 8/10/3 by the 8-wood location & by a 3:1 port, DiGuillo took the 8/4/10 by the 8-brick, 4-brick and the brick port and finally Osteen took two locations in the middle that had neither a 6 nor an 8. With the initial placements decided, the 6-wood location was bordered by DiGuillo, Colin and Metzger (aka the robber magnet). This gave DiGuillo a 6-wood and an 8-brick and Metzger a 6-wood and a 6-wheat. Of the five commodities, ORE was the hardest hit with a 2, a 3 and a 10-roll needed. Thus cities and development cards would be sparse.

EARLY GAME (Rounds 1-6): Each player started off by trading for a second road and eventually a third settlement; Colin and Metzger went for the 3:1 port, Osteen went to the 2:1 sheep port while DiGuillo headed for the 2:1 Brick port. This was the key build in the game as it gave him a 4 and an 8 for brick. Jeremy was then deemed the brick-master. Building was slow after the first settlements were completed, but Metzger was building the coastal road and had four roads and three settlements. Soon the longest road would go along the outside. Both Osteen and DiGuillo were cut into two parts but could link through the middle of the map as it was not built yet. The robber appeared in the first 6 of 7 rounds, slowing down production. Score: Metzger: 6, Colin: 4, DiGuillo: 4, Osteen:4. Army count: none.

MIDGAME (Rounds 7-13): Metzger completed her longest road bonus on Round 9; after that was done, players seemed to back off trading with her for building materials. On the same round, Jeremy benefited from a triple 8-roll and cashed in his massive bricks for ore, building the first city on the 4/8/10 spot. Rounds 10-12 saw the first development cards being purchased and a few soldiers were used to push the robber off the 8-6-8 locations. DiGuillo got a double 8 in Round 12 that allowed him to build a second city. Colin played a year of plenty and on Turn 13 did a monopoly on BRICK, giving her a road path that was one connection short of taking the longest road from Metzger. Score: Metzger: 7, Colin: 4, DiGuillo: 6, Osteen: 6. Army count: DiGuillo: 1, Colin: 1.

End game (Rounds 14-16): Metzger still maintained the longest road but only by one length. Colin needed a critical link to take it from her, but never built it. Metzger, tarred by the lead, found her trading partners exhausted. Osteen and Metzger tried to work out a deal: a favor for a commodity, but because of the trading rules (card for a card), it was not allowed. By then, DiGuillo played his second soldier and moved the robber off of the 8-brick, which now had a DiGuillo city and two settlements with the 2:1 port -- essentially giving him four bricks on any 8 roll. Round 16 rolled two 8s and on Jeremy's turn he rolled a 5, turned in his eight bricks for a city and played his last soldier, giving him the largest army and the win with ten points!

FINAL GAME STATS: Rolls: one 3, five 4s, seven 5s, nine 6s, twelve 7s, eleven 8s, seven 9s, four 10s, two 11s, and four 12s. SCORE: Jeremy: 10, Natasha: 7, Kolbe: 6 and Virginia: 4.

I need another Assistant GM. Contact me if you are interested at striker511@gmail.com. Lastly, Mayfair Games was kind enough to send me a ton of items to give out, but they arrived a week too late for the tournament. However, I will bring them with me for winners of any game in the 2013 Settlers even, so come back next year to trade sheep for wood as I will have some loot to hand out to winners!

Joseph Mais and his GM crew oversee the finalists.

Joe presents the finalists with their swag.


 Settlers Junior

In the Juniors event 26 pint-sized settlers engaged in empire building on a smaller scale under the watchful eye of GM Tim Mossman. The best proved to be Antony Saccenti, (age 12) followed by Dante Saccenti (11). Nicholas Metzger (12) for the third year in a row finished in the top three. Mandy Mossman (11) finished fourth (up from sixth last year), and Aiden Powers (9) and Caitlyn Rau (12) took fifth and sixth


2012 Euro Quest Laurelists

Robert Kircher, RI
1st

Cary Morris, NC
2nd

Brian Reynolds, MD
3rd

Henry Dove, MD
4th

Donna Davis, PA
5th

 GM      Joseph Maiz  [4th Year]   NA
   striker511@gmail.com    NA 

2012 Preview Page | View the Icon Key | Return to main BPA page