twilight struggle   

Updated Feb. 11, 2013

2012 WBC Report  

 2013 Status: pending 2013 GM commitment

Riku Riekkinen, fn

2012 Champion

Event History
2006    Stefan Mecay     70
2007    Stefan Mecay     66
2008    Stefan Mecay     54
2009    Chris Withers     66
2010    Stefan Mecay     57
2011    Stefan Mecay     55
2012    Riku Riekkinen    64

WAM Event History
2007    Keith Wixson     30
2008    Marvin Birnbaum     35
2009     Stefan MeCay     28
2010    Chris Byrd     21
2011    Stefan MeCay     27
2012    Chris Byrd     30
2013    Chris Byrd     20

PBeM Event History
2008    Stefan Mecay     86

 Laurels

Rank  Name              From  Last  Total
  1.  Stefan Mecay       TX    11    413
  2.  Chris Withers      CA    12    161
  3.  Keith Wixson       NJ    13    143
  4.  Marvin Birnbaum    NY    13    108
  5.  Rick Young         NC    09    100
  6.  Chris Byrd         CT    12     82
  7.  Bill Edwards       VA    13     60
  8.  Riku Riekkinen     fn    12     60
  9.  Bruce Monnin       OH    11     46
 10.  Paul Sampson       OH    12     43
 11.  Randy Pippus       on    12     42
 12.  Michael Mitchell   GA    13     37
 13.  James Terry        NJ    11     37
 14.  Rob Hassard        NJ    10     32
 15.  Stuart Tucker      MD    08     31
 16.  John Emery         SC    06     30
 17.  Steven Brooks      FL    10     29
 18.  George Seary       NY    08     28
 19.  Sean McCulloch     OH    09     25
 20.  Roderick Lee       CA    11     24
 21.  Darren Kilfara     uk    08     24
 22.  George Young       VT    10     21
 23.  Phil Rennert       MD    08     20
 24.  M. Pare-Paquin     qc    12     18
 25.  Kevin Hammond      WA    11     16
 26.  Tim Bina           CA    11     16
 27.  Mike Wallschlaeger WI    09     15
 28.  John Buse          IL    06     15
 29.  Jeff Finkeldey     OH    13     12
 30.  Larry Fryer        MD    12     12
 31.  Bruce DuBoff       NJ    08     10
 32.  Derek Landel       NJ    11      8
 33.  Doug Austin        VA    07      8
 34.  David Amidon       PA    12      6
 35.  Suzanne Tuch       NY    08      6
 36.  Dave Gerson        CA    09      5
 37.  John Wetherell     PA    09      5
 38.  Michael Sosa       FL    08      5
 39.  Kevin Earle        VA    12      4
 40.  C. Georgantzas     NY    11      4
 41.  Charles Hickok     PA    07      4
 42.  Randy MacInnis     NJ    13      3

2012 Laurelists                                                Repeating Laurelists: 0

Chris Withers, CA
2nd

Paul Sampson, OH
3rd

Mathieu Pare-Paquin, qc
4th

Randy Pippus, on
5th

David Amidon, PA
6th

Past Winners

Stefan Mecay, TX
2006-08, 2010-11

Chris Withers, CA
2009

Riku Riekkinen, fn
2012

Eli Persky draws the Finnish POG champ.

Keith Wixson vs Randy Pippus

 Anthony Raimo escapes the Showroom.

 Chris Byrd vs Derek Landel

Riku Wargames the Field ...

Notwithstanding the heat and humidity of Lampeter, Twilight Struggle posted a nice attendance increase. In addition, more total games (78) were played than in recent years as many took advantage of the new swiss format to play more rounds, including the 4th place finisher, Matthieu Pare-Paquin, who missed the first round but won his next four games. Cold Warriors appear to be heartier than other wargamers as we did not see the attendance falloff suffered by most tournaments in Lampeter.

The tournament used two adjustments to dampen the early war VP swings that often favor the Russians. The main option was the use of the Chinese Civil War variant, which prevents early Russian play of Red Scare and has other balancing effects. In addition, players bid for sides; typical bids gave the US 2-3 additional influence at start.

After four rounds of play, only three unbeatens remained: Riku Riekkinen, Chris Withers, and Paul Sampson. Philip Burgin-Young was randomly selected among those with one loss to complete the final four. Riku was paired with Paul, and accepted the Americans for a bid of 3. The USSR took an early edge with some good coup rolls and early play of Destalinization. Riku nonetheless controlled the tempo for significant periods, neutralizing areas immediately prior to scoring and using final action rounds to disrupt the position at the end of the turn. The game ended on Turn 10 when Riku played Wargames. In the other match, the Russians got off to a poor start and Chris's Americans never let Philip recoup.

Riku took the Soviets in the Final with a bid of 3. Early Destalinization enabled the Russians to gain a favorable position in Asia, which the Americans partially offset by taking Europe. Still, Early War ended with the Russians up 7 VPs. In Mid War, the battle shifted to Central America, then South America; by the end of Turn 5, the Americans had pulled back to -1 VPs, but the Russians gained a more favorable board position. This produced a -6 lead at the end of Mid War, with a strong Russian position in the Mideast giving the Russians an edge. Riku increased the VPs by one more, then dropped Wargames for the win on Turn 9.

Game play, as usual, favored the Russians, even with the Chinese Civil War and bidding. The Russians won 49 games; US 29. This is a fairly large edge so balance provisions will be reexamined before next year's tournament.

Paul Sampson vs Ted Lyng

Chris Withers is denied by Riku in the Final.

With WAM attendance down from its strong showing in 2012, it was inevitable that attendance for TWS would take a hit as well. After all, TWS has been one of the top draws for WAM for several years. Its showing of 20 players this year was nearly three-fourths of the WAM field. Certainly, there was no lack of passion among the participants, with a number of games making it to the Final War deck, and a handful being decided by final scoring after Turn 10. The intensity was fueled by the fact that both the previous WAM TWS champs, Chris Byrd and Stefan Mecay, were absent—which meant that with the right amount of guile and luck, one big upset could potentially put you in the Final. The smaller field also meant that one mistake could knock you right out of the running, as we needed only four rounds to crown a champion.

The first round got off to a rousing start when Marvin Birnbaum forced Mark Yoshikawa to blow up the world on Turn 5. Charlie Hickok steered his Soviets to a similar victory vs George Galuschak on the very same turn, but gained a few more style points, since his victory was punctuated by Kruschchev banging his shoe on a table. Not to be outdone, Randy MacInnis managed an auto-victory with the USSR on Turn 3. Responding with US automatic wins were Keith Wixson over Bruce Monnin and David Amidon over Roderick Lee. And in true WAM tradition, there were a number of games that came down to the last turns. Derek Landel built up an 18-point lead over Terry Coleman, only to see Terry charge back within 7 by Turn 9. A timely play of the Wargames card allowed Derek to escape with a narrow victory that both players called their most exciting game of the event. Michael Sosa repeated this ploy almost exactly in defeating Kirk Harris. Two games came down to Final Scoring, with Doug Austin and Michael Mitchell defeating Bill Edwards and Larry Fryer, respectively.

Doug would continue his excellent play with a win over another good player, Jeff Finkeldey, in Round 2. That, however, was the end of Mr. Austin's WAM adventure, as he left for home before the last rounds. Also improving to 2-0 were Keith Wixson, Marvin Birnbaum, Randy MacInnis, and Michael Mitchell, whose Final Scoring victory over Charlie was one of the tenser contests of the tournament.

The marquee matchups had Marvin bulldozing again to a Soviet auto win, this time versus Randy, and Michael pulling out a Final Scoring victory against Keith. They would meet for the title. Meanwhile, several early-round losers had gone on a winning streak to put them in striking distance of laurels. Jeff had the perfect combo to force Mark Yoshikawa to DEFCON 1 and a loss, enticed Derek into his own mushroom cloud, and might have done the same to Greg Ottoman, had not the latter resigned on Turn 7. Similarly, Keith forced a resignation from Randy in the last round—a consolation of sorts for not making the championship game. Bill bounced back from his opening-round loss with three straight wins over Terry Coleman, Bruce Monnin and Roderick Lee (who finished 2nd at WAM 2011). All of these results would seem to point to a thrilling Final but it was not to be. Marvin jumped out to a huge lead. All of his early coups were successful, and for Michael, just the opposite was true. Marvin sprinted to an automatic victory on Turn 3, and achieved his second WAM TWS crown, and the first since 2008.

We played with 2nd edition TWS rules, but also included the two additional influence in Canada for the US from the Deluxe version. Also, the holder of the China Card at the end of the game was awarded only 1/2 victory point, to avoid any chance of a draw. Only seven games used the optional cards from the Deluxe set, and no one played with Chinese Civil War rules - the consensus at WAM seems to be that with seasoned players, the main effect of these rules is to keep the China Card out of the game altogether.

Unlike last year, when the US held a slight edge, the Soviets won going away, by a margin of 20-12. Much of the blame for this can be laid at the feet of our champ, Marvin Birnbaum, who led the Russian blitz with a perfect 4-0 Soviet slate. His counterpart, Jeff Finkeldey played the US in all four games, finishing with the best American record at 3-1.

2013 WAM Laurelists

Michael Mitchell, GA 3-1
2nd

Jeff Finkeldey, OH 3-1
3rd

Keith Wixson, NJ 3-1
4th

Bill Edwards, VA 3-1
5th

Randy MacInnis, NJ 2-2
6th

 GM      George Young (4th Year)  NA  
    gyoung20@aol.com   802-578-3774

2012 Preview Page | View the Icon Key | Return to main BPA page