Breakout: Normandy — Results PBeM Tournament #2 (2001)
January 9, 2006

BKN PBeM #5 | BKN PBeM #4 | BKN PBeM #3 | BKN PBeM #2 | BKN PBeM #1

1st: John Crabtree
2nd: Alan Applebaum
3rd: Tom Drueding
4th: Michael Kaye
5th: Jim Doughan
6th: Tom Gregorio

Overall: The Germans won 23 of the 37 games played. Supply bids escalated every round as the survivors showed their preference for the Germans. Despite this, John Crabtree wins as the Allies behind strong assault dice by taking Caen on the 10th against the vaunted German defense of WBC champ Applebaum in a game played in less than a week.

 

Round-By-Round Results

Round 1 — Matches ended Nov. 3, 2001, or upon all completion, whichever occurred first.
Germans won 11 of 18 games with an average supply bid handicap of 3.9 due to 10 players preferring to play the Allies.

 Allies Germans
Bid
Winner
Marvin Birnbaum Nick Markevich
0
 Allies
Nick Frydas James Doughan
0
 Germans
Ken Nied Phil Barcafer
0
 Germans
Anthony Daw Bob Ryan
0
 Allies
John Howell Andrew Cummins
0
 Germans
Bill Edwards Henry Jones
0
 Germans
Al Bard Dennis Nicholson
0
 Germans
Tom Dworschak John Crabtree
0
 Germans
Rob Haden George Young
0
 Germans
Michael Rinella Bryan Thompson
0
 Allies
Mark Gutfreund Alan Applebaum
+15 Allied Supply
 Germans
Tom Drueding Bruno Passacantando
+7 Allied Supply
 Allies
Jim Pyle Steve Andriakos
+6 Allied Supply
 Germans
Mike Kaye Bryan Eshleman
+5 Allied Supply
 Allies
Philip Smith Jim Eliason
+10 Allied Supply
 Allies
Richard Tucker Ron Fedin
+5 Allied Supply
 Germans
Tom Gregorio Mike Brophy
+7 Allied Supply
 Allies
Paul Fletcher Don Greenwood
+16 Allied Supply
 Germans

Round 2 — Matches ended April 14, 2002, or upon all completion, whichever occurred first.
The Germans won five of ten games with an average bid 10.3 supply points. In the Consolation Round, the Germans took four of five with one game continuing off the ladder. Thanks to a bidding match for the Allies, the average in the Consolation round was a mere 2.3 for the Germans.

 
 Allies Germans
Bid
Winner
 Anthony Daw  Alan Applebaum
 0
 Germans
 Mike Rinella  Marvin Birnbaum
 0
 Allies
 Tom Drueding  Phil Barcafer
 -12
 Allies
 Andrew Cummins  Henry Jones
 -13
 Allies
 Ron Fedin  George Young
 -11
 Allies
 Philip Smith  Don Greenwood
-18
 Germans
 Dennis Nicholson  John Crabtree
 -12
 Germans
 Steve Andriakos  Jim Doughan
 -15
 Germans
 Mark Gutfreund (Eliminator)  Michael Kaye
-12
 Germans
 Tom Gregorio  Bryan Eshleman (Eliminator)
-10
 Allies
Consolation Round
 Don Greenwood  Tom Dworschak
 -13
 Germans
 Nick Markevich  Bill Edwards
 -7
 Allies
 Ken Nied  Paul Fletcher
 -10
 Allies
 Tyler Gingrich  Jim Pyle
-5
 Germans
 Bob Jamelli  John Howell
 0
 Germans
 Kevin Shewfelt  Alan Bard
 +15
 Germans

Round 3 — Matches ended Aug. 15, 2002, or upon all completion, whichever occurred first. The Consolation Round ended on Sept. 16, 2002.
And then there were five. Round 3 ended nearly three months before the deadline, as the remaining unbeaten players showed how quickly the game can be played. The Germans won four of five games with an average bid of 16.2 supply points. It seems the bids escalate as the rounds progress.


 Allies  Germans
 Bid
 Winner
 Andrew Cummins  Alan Applebaum
­17
 Germans
 Don Greenwood  John Crabtree
­22
 Germans
 Ron Fedin  Jim Doughan
­15
 Germans
 Tom Gregorio  Tom Drueding
­12
 Germans
 Michael Kaye  Mike Rinella
­12
 Allies
 Consolation Round
 Marvin Birnbaum   Tom Dworschak
­ 8
 Allies
 Ron Fedin  Jim Eliason
­10
 Germans
 Steve Andriakos  Mark Gutfreund
­12
 Germans
 Phil Barcafer  Henry Jones
­19
 Allies
 George Young  Tom Gregorio
­12
 Allies
 Dennis Nicholson  Paul Fletcher
­15
 Allies
 John Howell  Jim Pyle
­3
 Germans
 Anthony Daw  Phil Smith
­12
 Germans
 Bob Jamelli  Kevin Shewfelt
0
 Allies
 Bryan Thompson  Bryan Eshleman
0
 Germans

Round 4 — Matches ended Oct. 31, 2002, or upon all completion, whichever occurred first.
Consolation Ladder head Tom Dworschak served as an Eliminator in Round 4. As he was successful, he shortened the tournament by one round, with Round 5 as the Finals.

Allies Germans
Bid
Winner
Jim Doughan Alan Applebaum
­20
 Germans
Michael Kaye John Crabtree
­15
 Germans
Tom Drueding Tom Dworschak (Eliminator)
­18
 Germans

Round 5 Final Match: Round 5 ended by Feb. 4, 2003.

Allies Germans
Bid
Champion
John Crabtree Alan Applebaum
­19
 Allies

Boardgame Players Association Last updated 1/9/06 by kae.
© Copyright 2006 by the Boardgame Players Association.
Trademarks are property of their respective holders.