Alas, poor Hamburg!
Robert Seulowitz ponders a move
during the Semi-Finals.
The 2000 tournament will probably go down in WBC history as
the year that all tables saw a winner other than Hamburg! The
London position, meanwhile, had but one win! Will this mean an
increase in bids next year? This year's highest bid was a '7',
a far cry from the double-digit bids of years past. However,
the average bid was up from last year, at 2.2, with many players
opting for the 3 to 4 bid range and '0' bids losing favor.
Victories, by position: 
* Barcelona: 9
* Paris: 7
* Venice: 5
* Genoa: 4
* London: 1
* Hamburg: 0
In all, five of 26 games were played with only five players
(no Hamburg).
Victories, by bid:
* 0 - 4 winners
* 1 - 1 winner
* 2 - 4 winners
* 3 - 12 winners
* 4 - 4 winners
* 6 - 1 winner
Winning bids thus tended to be higher than the 2.2 average.
Last-place position, by bid: Lauren Hickok (right) prepares her forces in the opening
Heat.
NA - 3 (multiple chaos, etc.)
* 0 - 5 losers
* 1 - 7 losers
* 2 - 5 losers
* 3 - 3 losers
* 5 - 3 losers
Thus, more than half of all last-place finishers bid less
than 2.
Some heated game action:
* Tony Bovo's Paris is the only position with Cathedral,
but Ed Wrobel's low-profile Venice nudges by Ted Simmons' much-less-miserable
Barcelona.
* Scott Marcotte's Barcelona is the only one with Holy
Indulgence on Turn 3 and never looks back. Meanwhile, Eric Eshleman's
Venice reaches 900 Misery but somehow comes roaring back to challenge
Rob Seulowitz's London, Steve Simmons' Genoa and Rob Flowers'
Hamburg.
* Olin Hentz's Barcelona bids a conservative -12 on the
final turn to make sure he can cash in his two Spice and one
Silk for
over $500.
* Ewan McNay's Genoa plays War on Turn 1, loses his capital,
never recaptures it, but goes on to be the only buyer of Cathedral,
then of Ocean Navigation, and swamps the competition.
And finally, a 1st-person narration of the Sunday Final by
the Genoese winner, Ewan McNay:
Venice (bid 5): Jim Jordan
Barcelona (bid 5): Olin Hentz
Genoa (bid 4): Ewan McNay
London (bid 3): Jeff Mullett
Paris (bid 3): Tom Taaffe
Hamburg (bid 1): Harald Henning
Perhaps the best-played game of AoR, in terms of skill, that
I've ever been a part of--six extremely good players, at least
five of whom could plausibly be called the leader right to the
end.
After a quiet (but long--negotiations started intensely and
early with Hamburg asking for Bordeaux!) opening move, Turn 2
saw a Venetian-backed Civil War wrack Genoa to ensure that the
Venetian merchants would have first crack at the riches of the
Near East. The Spanish merchants, meanwhile, forgot to spend
time working on their shipping and were left paddling in the
Western Med. This turn also saw a British incursion into Lubeck
expelled by Parisian forces, at the invitation of Hamburg-- Paris
would go on to take Milan also, and specialize in Stone. The
first of two rebellions broke out in Marseilles.
Both Genoa and London sprang ahead on Turn 3, as Walter's
aid was sought by the Genoese in getting a lock on the Black
Sea, and the Crusaders of London brought the British into the
Far East in one fell swoop. At this stage, Genoa had something
like 16 cities, and the income from them enabled a lead in advances
that was to last until the end of the game. Indeed, the rest
of Genoa's game was a story of relatively few tokens bid, poor
dice rolled, but enough leaders and small payoffs to keep a nose
ahead in the Advance column - and a sufficiently small board
presence to be not worth attacking (in my opinion, anyway!).
The leaders were really key - I had Ibn Majid, Walter, Henry,
Oldenburg, de las Casas and maybe others. In particular, I think
that Henry came out (protected) while my city income was still
high, and the purchase of Institutional Research was another
key factor in allowing my relatively low income to stretch. Paris
opines that the play of all three Civics leaders in the protected
box was a key element separating players early on.
While Barcelona fell slowly from contention, perhaps, with
a plague depriving him of several payouts at a key moment, a
slow Venetian start was kicked into high gear by a $160 Ivory
payout - allowing them to get to the New World first, as well
as the Far East, and gain a strong position in Spice, Gold and
Metal. Paris rampaged through Central Europe, and at one stage
looked unstoppable, with a huge empire and money pouring in -
an $80 cloth payout after taking Tunis, and rewards from sponsorship
of both Columbus and (I think) Newton that same turn. London
had several silk payouts, but - along with Paris - was getting
ever more miserable. The British had pioneered religious warfare,
with first Holy Indulgence and then Cathedral, and followed that
by a Papal ban on Religion, making themselves a huge target but
also suffering from Religious Strife and loss of a War to Barcelona,
as well as a second plague in the British Isles - although the
remaining defenders proved extremely stout, fighting off several
incursions by Genoese and Spanish forces against all odds. Hamburg
meanwhile had been collecting vast numbers of cards - shortages
in timber every turn, it seemed - but had relatively little board
position despite a violent attack on grain provinces just after
they had been taken by Genoa :-). Still, while having fairly
low income and few leaders until late, and keeping quiet in the
contention over leadership, a check on Advances purchased revealed
that the Hamburgers' position was actually very strong.
As the endgame approached, Genoa had a small reserve of cash
(from leader patronage) which multiplied itself through Interest
and Profit, while both Paris and Hamburg owned Renaissance and
Venice had perhaps the best board position in commodities to
come. The usual flurry of violent cards saw Pirates raid the
Venetian colony in S. America as well as their grain in Seville
- this after Genoa had taken all of the Parisian grain, only
to have some of it taken in turn by others. The import of grain
was revealed when a Famine occurred - and the misery from that
sent Paris out of contention. However, the threat of Pirate attacks
on their grain had persuaded London's agitators to turn their
attentions from Genoa to Venice, and that Civil War knocked down
the Venetians also. As the final cash payouts were tallied, a
slender lead in Advance values gave the advantage to Genoa over
Hamburg. And we could all go home.
|